Anecdotally, I've heard before that Biotech stocks do well in the fall due to the preponderance of trade/medical conferences where they highlight their clinical findings, pipelines and emerging technologies. The thought is that since the most prominent venues occur in the fall, the frenzy surrounding their prospects swells in the fall and then subsides at the end of the year. To date though, I've never seen any actual data to support this claim. So, I decided to do some research. My findings actually support this claim and I have the perfect strategy to capitalize on this phenomena:
My findings indicate that based on the return of the Biotech Holders ETF (BBH), their is a very strong correlation with high average returns, median returns and positive returns for the months of Sep, Oct, Nov that occurs only during that 3 month span. I chose BBH because it is a prominent ETF that has several years of history. Be aware that the ETF is heavily weighted in Amgen and Genentech since it is based on market cap. Going back several years, these companies were very much representative of the industry. If you want broader diversification for this strategy, other options out there are IBB and XBI, which have different weightings.
What the attached chart shows is that over 7 years, there was only one span of 3 months that on average, had positive returns more than half that time. There was only one span of 3 months that had both positive median AND mean returns. The average return during those 3 months exceeded 3%. These 3 months were Sep, Oct, Nov. If you leverage that into a 2x fund (below), that's 6% you could capitalize on each year, which is close the the long-run average return for an entire year! Take into consideration standard deviation of course. To be more conservative, consider the market neutral option below. To take it to the next level, you could actually sell your holdings or short the indices listed due to the poor performance in December. There are myriad iterations of this strategy that could be employed, but the bottom line is, there's now some strong trends and data to support what used to be Wall Street lore to me.
There are several ways to exploit this trend:
- For the ultimate return, utilizing a leveraged basis, you could employ the Profunds Ultra Biotech fund, which provides double the return of Dow Jones U.S. Biotech index. Proshares has not yet launched a Biotech ETF, so for now, you'd have to go the fund route, which might carry a fee/high minimum with it, depending on your online trading account.
- For a market neutral play (assumes the Biotech index will outperform the general market), you could go long one of the ETFs listed above and short the major indices. If selling ETFs/shares short makes you nervous, which it should, there are long ways to bet against the market. SH is the inverse of the S&P and SDS is 2x negatively correlated ETF, both by Proshares.
Link to Profunds Ultra Biotech:
http://www.profunds.com/ProFundsProfiles/FundID_403/Biotechnology/Profile.fs
Disclosure: I am not long any of the Biotech ETFs listed here, but may consider this strategy within the next few weeks. I will update if pursued.
Screen Shot of Data Table (click to enlarge):

.
.











6 COMMENTS HERE
Ned Davis Research has plenty on seasonality of industries, and came to the same conclusions you did. Usually large cap biotech leads small cap heading into the fall.
It's good to know there are other resources out there; thanks for validating that I'm not off the mark.
Unfortunately, NDR looks to be a paid service requiring login credentials for institutional investors and the like.
I guess for the free stuff, folks have to look around for sites like this. I will continue perform/post independent research as I come up with new ideas. Until next time, enjoy!
great blog...keep posting your insights...much appreciated!!
This article was featured at SeekingAlpha:
http://www.seekingalpha.com/article/45476-profiting-from-the-cyclical-nature-of-biotech-stocks
This article was also featured in the most recent Carnival of Finance, which can be accessed at:
http://www.freemoneyfinance.com/2007/08/carnival-of-per.html
As a corrolary, AGIX was up 40% today (including the After Hours) on simply this news:
"announcing it will release new scientific data on its antidiabetic agent AGI-1067 at this year's European Society of Cardiology Congress on Sept. 5."
If only I'd picked that one...
But the same logic prevails. Tis' the season...
http://www.thestreet.com/_yahoo/newsanalysis/winnerssmallcap/10377079.html?cm_ven=YAHOO&cm_cat=FREE&cm_ite=NA
Not to beat a dead horse, but following yesterday's comment, AGIX was up another 21% today. That's close to net 70% increase from base in 2 days.
Post a Comment